Sample deliverable
Operations and Cost Diagnostic, on a synthetic AP function
What the diagnostic delivers, shown on the accounts payable function of a synthetic US wholesale distributor, the same company as in the Reporting Trust Review sample: 11,800 vendor invoices in 2025, a cost model from the ledger, the workflow as it runs, and a 90-day roadmap.
Payables cost $24.15 an invoice. Four changes would return about $54,516 a year, mostly as staff time.
The company is made up for this sample. Its accounts payable function cost $284,943 in 2025: $240,027 in the AP cost center's ledger and $44,915 of approvers' and buyers' time logged outside it, $24.15 for each of 11,800 invoices. The workflow log shows exceptions taking 887 hours of AP time, 44% more than the team reported, and chasing approvals more than twice what was reported. Four changes, under assumptions listed one by one below, would return about $54,516 a year: $8,594 of it as cash, the rest as 1,121 hours of staff time (0.64 of a full-time position) freed for other work.
| Annual cost of the function | $284,943 |
|---|---|
| Cost per invoice | $24.15 |
| AP minutes per invoice, from the log | 17.6 |
| Invoices with an exception | 16.5% |
| Early-payment discounts missed | $40,040 |
| Net annual saving of the four changes | $54,516 |
| Of which cash, after running costs | $8,594 |
| One-time cost of the four changes | $14,000 |
What the function costs, from the accounting data
| Component, 2025 | Source | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| AP staff: salaries, payroll taxes and benefits | Ledger 6100, 6150 | $216,320 |
| Temporary staff in peak months | Ledger 6180 | $2,880 |
| Paying by check: postage, check stock, bank fees | Ledger 6420, 6430, 6510 | $5,469 |
| Paying by ACH: bank fees | Ledger 6520 | $622 |
| AP software | Ledger 6610 | $13,800 |
| Late payment charges | Ledger 6710 | $937 |
| Approvers' and buyers' time outside AP | Workflow log, at the assumed hourly cost | $44,915 |
| Total | $284,943 |
Staff, in AP and temporary, is 76.9% of the cost, at a loaded $40.97 an hour of AP capacity. Unit costs come from the ledger divided by the volumes in the payment records: a check costs $1.95 in postage, stock and bank fees across 2,798 checks, an ACH payment $0.22 across 2,826. The salaries in the ledger tie to the headcount (1 AP supervisor, 2 AP clerks); the script stops if they do not.
Missed discounts are not in the ledger, because a discount not taken leaves no entry. 65.7% of the 3,852 invoices offering 2% for payment within ten days got it; the discounts missed total $40,040, $25,470 of them on invoices that waited for an approval.
The workflow as it runs today
The steps in the order an invoice meets them, with how often each one was performed in 2025 and the hours it took.
Receipt and entry
Every invoice: opened or downloaded, keyed into the ERP (EDI arrives keyed).
11,800 times; 1,050 AP hours.
Coding
Invoices without a PO: GL account and cost center chosen by a clerk.
4,484 times; 263 AP hours.
Matching
Invoices against a PO: matched to the PO and the goods receipt.
7,316 times; 397 AP hours.
Exceptions
Invoices that fail matching or coding, or look like a duplicate: resolved with buyers, the warehouse or the vendor.
1,942 times; 887 AP hours, 383 hours outside AP.
Approval
Invoices without a PO and every exception: approved by a manager outside AP.
6,081 times; 277 hours outside AP.
Chasing approvals
Approvals waiting five days or more: a clerk follows up.
3,287 times; 412 AP hours.
Payment run
Weekly run: one payment per vendor; checks printed, signed and mailed.
5,676 times; 279 AP hours.
Vendor inquiries
Vendors calling or writing about payment status.
1,110 times; 175 AP hours.
Median time from receipt to approved for payment: 4 days; one invoice in ten took 14 days or more. 1.5% of invoices were paid after their due date.
Logged hours against what the team reported
| Activity | Logged hours | Share | Reported hours | Share |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Receipt and entry | 1,050 | 19.9% | 1,056 | 20% |
| Coding | 263 | 5% | 282 | 5.3% |
| Matching | 397 | 7.5% | 422 | 8% |
| Exceptions | 887 | 16.8% | 616 | 11.7% |
| Chasing approvals | 412 | 7.8% | 194 | 3.7% |
| Payment run | 279 | 5.3% | 546 | 10.3% |
| Vendor inquiries | 175 | 3.3% | 370 | 7% |
| Not in the log: close, vendor master and other | 1,818 | 34.4% | 1,795 | 34% |
| AP capacity | 5,280 | 100% | 5,280 | 100% |
The team reported how it splits its time; the workflow log measures it. Exceptions took 887 hours against 616 reported, and chasing approvals 412 against 194: the interruptions are the part people underestimate. The payment run and vendor inquiries took less than reported. Capacity is 3 full-time positions at 1,760 productive hours; the row not in the log is what remains, and covers the close, vendor master changes and supervision.
16.5% of invoices stopped for an exception
21.8% of invoices against a purchase order stopped, against 7.7% of invoices without one: more than twice as often. EDI invoices stopped least.
| Exception | Invoices | Share of invoices | AP minutes each | Minutes outside AP each | AP hours |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price variance | 735 | 6.23% | 25.9 | 11.9 | 318 |
| No goods receipt | 366 | 3.1% | 32.3 | 12.8 | 197 |
| Quantity variance | 302 | 2.56% | 31.1 | 15.1 | 156 |
| PO missing or closed | 153 | 1.3% | 43.7 | 18.9 | 111 |
| Coding query | 299 | 2.53% | 15.7 | 7 | 78 |
| Possible duplicate | 87 | 0.74% | 17.6 | 0 | 26 |
| Channel | Invoices | Share | Entry minutes each | Exception rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EDI | 1,165 | 9.9% | 0.5 | 13% |
| Email PDF | 6,327 | 53.6% | 4.7 | 17.1% |
| Paper | 4,308 | 36.5% | 7.5 | 16.4% |
The financial effect of each proposed change
Each change acts on a different step, so the savings add. Hours freed are valued at the loaded cost of AP time; they become cash only if they replace temporary staff, overtime or a hire. The 1,121 hours freed exceed the 80 temporary hours bought in 2025, so the temp spend is the first cash they can replace. The last column halves the change's main assumption.
| Change | Hours freed | Value of hours | Cash, after running cost | Net a year | One-time | Payback, months | Net, main assumption halved |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Invoice capture for emailed invoices | 481 | $19,688 | ($9,600) | $10,088 | $7,500 | 8.9 | $5,506 |
| Price tolerance on matching | 202 | $8,265 | ($68) | $8,198 | $2,000 | 2.9 | $4,804 |
| Pay check vendors by ACH | 109 | $4,463 | $3,397 | $7,860 | $1,500 | 2.3 | $3,930 |
| Approval routing with due dates | 330 | $13,505 | $14,865 | $28,370 | $3,000 | 1.3 | $18,819 |
| All four | 1,121 | $45,921 | $8,594 | $54,516 | $14,000 |
Invoice capture for emailed invoices
Ask paper-invoice vendors to email their invoices, and read emailed invoices with capture software instead of keying them.
Main assumption:
paperToEmailShare, 60%. Uses:paperToEmailShare,captureTouchlessShare,captureReviewMinutes,captureSoftwarePerYear,captureOneTime,captureEffortWeeks.Price tolerance on matching
Clear price variances automatically when they are within 2% of the invoice and $75; the variances accepted are paid and reported monthly to purchasing.
Main assumption:
priceTolerancePct, 2%. Uses:priceTolerancePct,priceToleranceCapUsd,outsideHourlyCost,toleranceOneTime,toleranceEffortWeeks.Pay check vendors by ACH
Ask the vendors paid by check for bank details and pay them by ACH; each check costs its postage, stock and bank fee, and longer in the run.
Main assumption:
checkVendorsToAch, 70%. Uses:checkVendorsToAch,achOneTime,achEffortWeeks.Approval routing with due dates
Route invoices to approvers with a due date set by the payment terms, and send reminders automatically instead of chasing by email and phone.
Main assumption:
missedDiscountsCaptured, 75%. Uses:missedDiscountsCaptured,lateFeesAvoided,chaseMinutesAvoided,routingSoftwarePerYear,routingOneTime,routingEffortWeeks.
Approval routing is where the cash is: $14,865 a year after its subscription, from discounts taken and late charges avoided. Moving checks to ACH saves $3,397 in postage, stock and bank fees. The price tolerance clears 467 invoices without a person, and the variances it accepts ($6,364) about cancel the 93 buyer hours it saves, so its saving is AP time. Invoice capture saves the most hours, 481, but its subscription costs more than any cash it saves: it pays only if the hours are used.
Every assumption behind the savings, one by one
Each is a named value in the model. Change one and rerun it, and the savings, the ranking and the roadmap follow.
| Name | Assumption | Value |
|---|---|---|
productiveHoursPerFte | Productive hours of one full-time employee, after leave and holidays | 1,760 hours a year |
outsideHourlyCost | Loaded cost of an hour of approvers' and buyers' time outside AP | $68.00 an hour |
paperToEmailShare | Paper-invoice vendors that agree to email their invoices | 60% |
captureTouchlessShare | Emailed invoices that invoice capture reads without keying | 65% |
captureReviewMinutes | Review time per invoice read by capture | 1 minute |
captureSoftwarePerYear | Invoice capture subscription | $9,600 a year |
captureOneTime | Capture setup and vendor outreach | $7,500 |
captureEffortWeeks | Elapsed weeks to put invoice capture live | 6 weeks |
priceTolerancePct | Price variance cleared automatically, up to this share of the invoice | 2% |
priceToleranceCapUsd | and up to this amount per invoice | $75 |
toleranceOneTime | Configuring and testing the tolerance in the ERP | $2,000 |
toleranceEffortWeeks | Elapsed weeks to put the tolerance live | 2 weeks |
checkVendorsToAch | Check-paid vendors that accept ACH when asked | 70% |
achOneTime | Collecting and verifying vendor bank details | $1,500 |
achEffortWeeks | Elapsed weeks to move the vendors | 4 weeks |
missedDiscountsCaptured | Missed early-payment discounts on invoices that waited for an approval, taken once approvals have due dates | 75% |
lateFeesAvoided | Late payment charges avoided once approvals have due dates | 60% |
chaseMinutesAvoided | Approval chasing no longer needed with automatic reminders | 80% |
routingSoftwarePerYear | Approval routing subscription | $4,800 a year |
routingOneTime | Approval rules, approver setup and training | $3,000 |
routingEffortWeeks | Elapsed weeks to put approval routing live | 4 weeks |
Ranked by saving and effort
The changes are ranked by net annual saving per week of effort and done one at a time, in that order. Three go live within the 90 days; invoice capture starts in week 11 and goes live in week 16. The first-year figure is the net saving for the weeks after go-live, within a year of the start, less the one-time cost.
| Rank | Change | Effort | Weeks | Live in week | Net, first year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Approval routing with due dates | Medium | 1 to 4 | 4 | $23,188 |
| 2 | Price tolerance on matching | Low | 5 to 6 | 6 | $5,252 |
| 3 | Pay check vendors by ACH | Medium | 7 to 10 | 10 | $4,849 |
| 4 | Invoice capture for emailed invoices | High | 11 to 16 | 16 (after day 90) | ($516) |
What this sample is and is not
- It is a sample, not client work. The company is the synthetic distributor of the Reporting Trust Review sample; its purchases follow that sample's deliveries, and its payables records are generated from a fixed seed. No real company or person is described.
- Every figure is computed by a script from six tables: vendors (420 rows), invoices (11,800 rows), workflow_log (43,551 rows), payments (5,624 rows), headcount (2 rows), gl_cost_lines (101 rows). The script stops on a missing value, an unexpected row count, or a ledger whose salaries do not tie to the headcount. Figures generated on 2026-11-16.
- The synthetic workflow log records every step of every invoice (43,551 rows). A client's systems rarely do; the engagement builds the same view from ERP timestamps, a short time study and the interviews, and says where it estimates.
- The savings are estimates under the assumptions listed, not measured results. Approvers' and buyers' time is valued at an assumed rate, because their pay is outside the AP cost center.
- It measures cost and time and ranks the changes. What to do with the hours freed is the company's decision.
The same diagnostic, on your function.
$7,500 fixed, two to three weeks. Tell us which function and what accounting data you keep for it.